Showing posts with label Space Marine Battles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Space Marine Battles. Show all posts

Thursday, 16 December 2010

The Purging of Kadillus - Gav Thorpe - Advanced Review


The Purging of Kadillus: Gav Thorpe
 A Space Marine Battles Novel

“Indeed it is Brothers. Today it is truly victory or Death.”

Faced with an ork invasion of Piscina IV, the 3rd Company of the Dark Angels believes the threat to be minimal. As enemy numbers continue to increase, their commander, Captain Belial, insists that his Company are strong enough to resist. But Scout-Sergeant Naaman knows just how dangerous this foe can be, and when a renewed greenskin offensive takes the Dark Angels by surprise, the orks swarm towards Kadillus Harbour. Little do the Dark Angels know of the technological power available to the xenos, and the true scale of the threat they face. Belial, Naaman and their fellow Astartes fight a desperate siege at Kadillus, knowing that they must hold out until Imperial reinforcements arrive or the planet will be lost.
~http://www.blacklibrary.com/all-products/coming-soon/The-Purging-of-Kadillus.html

Now then, it’s time for me to tell you what I thought of The Purging of Kadillus, the latest instalment in the Space Marine Battles series, written by Gav Thorpe, who also brought us novels like Path of the Warrior and Malekith. Now, before I read this book, out of the Space Marine Battles novels, I’ve only read Rynn’s World and Helsreach.

Because one book was excellent (Helsreach), and the other not so excellent (Rynn’s World), I was wondering whether the Dark Angels book would actually be any good, after eagerly waiting for it.

And was I entertained? Well, in a manner of speaking, yes. I was given a bolter-porn packed book that had some enjoyable fighting scenes, but apart from that, this book was defiantly no Helsreach.

The Purging of Kadillus didn’t really come of as a good book for me, as it lacked numerous things which make a book good, first of all – it lacked character development, and as mentioned earlier, was mainly bolter-porn, fast paced action that didn’t really put it above all others.

Now, the description in this novel was relatively okay, however Mr. Thorpe doesn’t really go into detail that much.

Back to the character development. Although, does people going from rivalries to respected companions throughout the whole novel count as character development? Because this does happen in the book, between Scout-Sergeant Naaman, as mentioned in the blurb, and Ravenwing-Sergeant Aquila.

Ah, now, Sergeant Aquila. This brings me onto the subject of names, and let’s just say, Gav Thorpe doesn’t keep them all original. Take the name of the Master Chaplain, for example. And, guess what he’s called: Uriel. Last time I checked, a Space Marine named Uriel Ventris just happened to be the main character of the Ultramarines series, written by popular author Graham McNeill.  

But wait, there’s more. Another Chaplain, an Interrogator this time, oh just so happens to bear the name of a Soul Drinkers character Sarpedon.

Now, moving on from the character names, I’m going to talk about the Orks. It’s our third Space Marine Battles novel out of four which features them as the opposition, and at long last, we finally get a bit from their point of view, in the prologue, and the epilogue. And it’s not just any Ork who we get a point of view from, oh no – it’s the almighty Hand of Gork and Mork himself, the Beast of Armageddon, Ghazghkull Thraka, and it’s pretty awesome, let me tell you this. From my point of view, it was one of the highlights of the book.

And on that bombshell, I leave you with this:

Rating: 6/10, an action packed book leaving little room for character development.

Should you buy this book? Unless you are a Space Marine Battles, Dark Angels or Gav Thorpe fan then you can probably give this book a miss.

Sunday, 15 August 2010

Rynn's World: Steve Parker

Okay, here's possibly my final review for a couple of weeks as I'll be on holiday in that period of time. During that, I'll be listining to Throne of Lies, reading Legion, Mechanicum, Tales of Heresy, Ultramarines Omnibus, Eisenhorn Omnibus and The Saint: A Gaunt's Ghosts Novel.

Rynn's World: Steve Parker

++Activate All frequency vox-net++



++Auth Gamma Five-Five-Two++

++Override Naval STS Relay++

++To all Imperial Forces in the Loki Sector++

++Rynn’s World orbital defence grid breached,

Surface-to-orbit batteries insufficient.

Crimson Fist battlefleet has sustained massive losses and cannot hold.

The Orks are landing upon Rynn’s World.

Situation Critical. Without aid, the planet will surely fall.

Request despatch of reinforcements from...++

++Transmission failed++

++There is only the Emperor, He is our shield and protector++

Okay, after reading Helsreach and enjoying it (see Of Books and Wargames 2), I decided to pick up Rynn’s World. And needless to say, I was disappointed.

I expected intense action, which I got. Pedro Kantor and the last few surviving Crimson Fists battling against all odds. I expected the Crimson Fists characters to be memorable, like the Helsreach novel. However, I was disappointed. These characters were entirely one dimensional. The battle for Rynn’s World had been one of my favourite 40K battles (behind The Siege of Terra and The Battle for Prospero), and I was glad that they at least made a book about it.

However, Steve Parker could have done better, for instance the invasion lasts for several months but it feels as though, per the book, it lasted only a week, and I didn’t feel as though the Chapter had any sort of way that made it unique, and I’m sure Brother Subtle of Drop Site Massacre will agree with me there.

I guess, there isn’t really any more to say about this, other than that I struggled to finish. I found myself skipping through pages to find out whether Alessio Cortez survived his clash with an Ork Warboss, and yeah, not an enjoyable book overall.

High Point: Kantor and Cortez’s bickering. They are two entirely opposite characters that have different views on everything (Kantor wants to save his chapter, Cortez wants a glorious last charge), but Cortez still respects his old friends will, as Pedro Kantor is the master of the Chapter after all.

Low Point: One Dimensional Characters, no uniqueness of the Crimson Fists.

Rating: 3/10 ¬ The lowest rating that I’d have to give a Black Library book yet.

Should you buy this book? If you want to have a collection of Space Marine Battles or enjoy one dimensional characters fighting against Orks.

~Bane of Kings, over and out. Expect loads of reviews when I get back hopefully.